Group Publishing
CMM0514
Subscribe Button

“We Write All Our Own Stuff”

Dreamstime _xs _16169461It seems to have become a badge of honor. "We don't use any outside resources."

Some people in ministry have decided to go it alone. They now spend a sizable chunk of their time creating their own curriculum, Bible studies, teacher guides, devotionals, messages, music, video and artwork.

I've heard a variety of reasons for this shift to homemade stuff. Such as:

  • "Nobody knows my people like I do. They have unique needs. I need to create material that is uniquely suited to them."
  • "My church expects me to create everything from scratch. If I don't, they'll wonder why they're paying me."
  • "Our church creates everything internally and brands it with our church name."
  • "I like being creative. This is my creative outlet."
  • "We can't afford professional materials."
  • "The Bible is all I need. Give me the Bible, the whole Bible, and nothing but the Bible."
  • "All the stuff on the market is garbage. I'm forced to create my own."

Though I understand some of the rationale, I'm concerned about the final outcomes and some of the side effects of being a Lone Ranger resourcer. And I'm concerned not just because I lead a publishing company. Sure, I'm interested in seeing our resources widely used. But I have a deeper concern and love for the effective work of the local church throughout God's Kingdom.

I too am a consumer of resources in my work and ministry. I appreciate the perspectives, expertise, and hard work that others build into their resources. I learned a long time ago that I can get a lot more done and accomplish my mission better when I rely on others to supply me with what they do best.

That's true in my work, and it's true in virtually every other line of work. Successful professionals everywhere look to outside professionals to provide the tools they need to accomplish their mission. You don't find many doctors concocting their own pharmaceuticals. You don't find many carpenters making their own lumber and nails. You don't find many airline pilots refining their own aviation fuel.

Yet some in the church feel compelled to attempt to do it all themselves. And it's distracting them from what they're really called to do. Their justifications for shunning outside help could use a re-examination.

"Nobody knows my people like I do." That may be true. But in a largely homogenous society with access to mass communications, your people share more similarities than differences with the rest of the population. In the larger landscape, today's national brands, mass media and franchises effectively connect with people in every community nationwide. Similarly, a good ministry resource connects with people in your church as well as people in thousands of other churches.

"My church expects me to create everything from scratch." If that's true, it may be time to clarify your written job description-to focus it on ministering to people.

"Our church creates everything internally and brands it with our church name." Shunning anything that is NIH (not invented here) is less about excellence than it is about pride. As powerful (and ugly) as pride is, nobody comes to your church because you do your own manufacturing. They don't care about your branding. They just want to experience God.

"This is my creative outlet." Hopefully, your ministry isn't about you. Find ways to exercise your creativity that do not deny your people of more effective resources. Remind yourself of that desperate yearning to escape when you endured another homespun song that Devin felt "led" to share with the captive congregation. Don't be Devin.

"We can't afford professional materials." So you spend countless hours building your own. What's your time worth? Help your church prioritize its stewardship toward those efforts that directly affect your people's spiritual growth.

"The Bible is all I need." If that's ultimately true, your people don't need you; just hand them a Bible and go home. However, it's better to follow Jesus' example. He used a variety of ideas, people and things to bring scriptural truths to life.

"All the stuff on the market is garbage." I understand. We've all been disappointed by inferior work. The world of ministry resources, like most other endeavors, includes a wide range of quality. There's some poor work, but there's also good work. Don't let the lackluster stuff keep you from finding and using good resources that will help you accomplish your mission.

The best ministry resources are created by gifted servants, pre-tested with actual participants, re-tested, refined, polished, and produced by seasoned teams of dedicated professionals. They're specialized members of the Body of Christ, who do their part so that others can do their part on the front lines of ministry.

And that's the true essence of the biblical picture of the Body of Christ. Each part does what it does best. "If the whole body were an eye, where would the sense of hearing be? If the whole body were an ear, where would the sense of smell be? But in fact God has placed the parts in the body, every one of them, just as he wanted them to be. If they were all one part, where would the body be?" (1 Cor. 12:17-19)

God doesn't call any one of us to do it all, to be proficient at everything. He simply calls us to be the part of the Body he created us to be. And to let others be the parts of the Body he created them to be. So that, together, the Body can accomplish the mission.

Posted at 09:58

9 Comments:

Ellen said...
You forgot the "our church matches the sermon" category. In our case, we are striving for the kids to learn the same concepts taking place in big church. that isn't usually possible in a box kit. On the other hand, we don't shy from borrowing what already exists on the internet. An interesting concept would be to put together lessons for the whole Bible (I do mean whole!) and allow consumers to purchase the "professionally" done ones that fit their sermon topics or set of topics. Now THAT would be awesome and save a lot of work.
February 21, 2014 05:51
Ellen said...
You forgot the "our church matches the sermon" category. In our case, we are striving for the kids to learn the same concepts taking place in big church. that isn't usually possible in a box kit. On the other hand, we don't shy from borrowing what already exists on the internet. An interesting concept would be to put together lessons for the whole Bible (I do mean whole!) and allow consumers to purchase the "professionally" done ones that fit their sermon topics or set of topics. Now THAT would be awesome and save a lot of work.
February 21, 2014 05:52
Ellen said...
You forgot the "our church matches the sermon" category. In our case, we are striving for the kids to learn the same concepts taking place in big church. that isn't usually possible in a box kit. On the other hand, we don't shy from borrowing what already exists on the internet. An interesting concept would be to put together lessons for the whole Bible (I do mean whole!) and allow consumers to purchase the "professionally" done ones that fit their sermon topics or set of topics. Now THAT would be awesome and save a lot of work.
February 21, 2014 05:53
LS said...
I am ministering in a foreign country, and most of the American material is irrelevant to our situation. On top of that, because many of the U.S. churches' children's ministries have the kids 2-3 hours on Sunday (children's church and Sunday school), the prepared curriculum has a lot of "fluff" to keep the kids busy. Although I've only written my own curriculum a couple of times over the years (because I couldn't find a prepared curriculum that covered the topic in the way I needed it to), I usually take prepared lessons from various places, put them together and adapt it for our group. Curriculum is a great tool--but even the experts can't foresee or know about each church's particular need or situation. I think there is a balance somewhere between producing your own curriculum or buying it--it isn't an "either/or" situation.
February 22, 2014 02:18
LS said...
I am ministering in a foreign country, and most of the American material is irrelevant to our situation. On top of that, because many of the U.S. churches' children's ministries have the kids 2-3 hours on Sunday (children's church and Sunday school), the prepared curriculum has a lot of "fluff" to keep the kids busy. Although I've only written my own curriculum a couple of times over the years (because I couldn't find a prepared curriculum that covered the topic in the way I needed it to), I usually take prepared lessons from various places, put them together and adapt it for our group. Curriculum is a great tool--but even the experts can't foresee or know about each church's particular need or situation. I think there is a balance somewhere between producing your own curriculum or buying it--it isn't an "either/or" situation.
February 22, 2014 02:19
LS said...
I am ministering in a foreign country, and most of the American material is irrelevant to our situation. On top of that, because many of the U.S. churches' children's ministries have the kids 2-3 hours on Sunday (children's church and Sunday school), the prepared curriculum has a lot of "fluff" to keep the kids busy. Although I've only written my own curriculum a couple of times over the years (because I couldn't find a prepared curriculum that covered the topic in the way I needed it to), I usually take prepared lessons from various places, put them together and adapt it for our group. Curriculum is a great tool--but even the experts can't foresee or know about each church's particular need or situation. I think there is a balance somewhere between producing your own curriculum or buying it--it isn't an "either/or" situation.
February 22, 2014 02:19
LS said...
I am ministering in a foreign country, and most of the American material is irrelevant to our situation. On top of that, because many of the U.S. churches' children's ministries have the kids 2-3 hours on Sunday (children's church and Sunday school), the prepared curriculum has a lot of "fluff" to keep the kids busy. Although I've only written my own curriculum a couple of times over the years (because I couldn't find a prepared curriculum that covered the topic in the way I needed it to), I usually take prepared lessons from various places, put them together and adapt it for our group. Curriculum is a great tool--but even the experts can't foresee or know about each church's particular need or situation. I think there is a balance somewhere between producing your own curriculum or buying it--it isn't an "either/or" situation.
February 22, 2014 02:19
said...
February 22, 2014 02:21
Brenda said...
I agree completely with both comments. I pull from many sources to create the unique approach that I need. Most curriculum do not address the need of 1 class, 1 teacher, many ages. I also have some curriculum that gets stuck on one kind of craft. That bores me, so I know it would bore the children.
March 29, 2014 08:57

Post a comment

Archive

 
Copyright © 2014 by Group Publishing, Inc.